Lawyer expects man to plead guilty in Dugard case |

Lawyer expects man to plead guilty in Dugard case

Associated Press
Phillip Garrido, who faces multiple charges for the 1991 kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, is seen during an arraignment hearing at the El Dorado County Superior County in Placerville, Calif., Thursday March 17, 2011. Garrido's attorney, Susan Gellman, asked for an extension in entering a plea as plea negotiations with prosecutors continues.(AP Photo)

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) – An attorney in the case of a Northern California girl held captive in a backyard compound for 18 years expects defendant Phillip Garrido to plead guilty to all charges in a decision that could be part of a strategy to help his wife, one legal expert says.

Lawyer Stephen Tapson, who represents defendant Nancy Garrido, said her husband will likely make the guilty plea Thursday at a pretrial conference but Nancy Garrido will go to trial unless she gets a better plea deal.

“Unless some hitch develops, I’m 99 percent sure Phil will ‘plead to the sheet’ and possibly be sentenced at the same time if (the) judge has figured out the correct number of hundreds of years,” Tapson said, explaining he learned of the development from discussions with a lawyer for Phillip Garrido and the prosecutor in the case.

Phillip Garrido’s expected guilty pleas by could be part of a strategy to help in his wife’s defense, according to Steven Clark, a San Francisco Bay area defense attorney and former prosecutor.

“He will testify on her behalf and essentially take as much as the fall as he can for her,” said Clark, who is not directly involved in the case.

Public defender Susan Gellman, who represents Phillip Garrido, did not immediately return a phone message seeking comment. El Dorado County District Attorney Vern Pierson declined to comment.

The Garridos are each charged with 18 felony counts of false imprisonment, rape and child pornography. Nancy Garrido has pleaded not guilty. Phillip Garrido, a convicted sex offender, has not yet entered a plea.

They are accused of kidnapping 11-year-old Jaycee Dugard from outside her South Lake Tahoe home in 1991.

Clark also speculated that guilty pleas by Phillip Garrido, while Nancy Garrido is expected to go to trial, could be part of a strategy to try to negotiate a lesser sentence for Nancy in order to keep Dugard from having to testify.

“This is a strategy that could help Nancy Garrido a lot,” said Clark.

If convicted on all counts, the maximum sentence for Nancy Garrido would be 181 years to life, while Phillip Garrido could get 431 years to life, according to El Dorado County Deputy District Attorney James Clinchard.

The Garridos held Dugard and her two daughters fathered by Phillip Garrido captive until their arrest in August 2009, prosecutors said.

Dugard’s case revealed problems with California’s system for monitoring convicted sex offenders after it was determined that parole agents had missed numerous clues and chances to find her.

Dugard, now 30, received a $20 million settlement under which the state acknowledged repeated mistakes were made by parole agents responsible for monitoring Phillip Garrido. The state has since increased monitoring of sex offenders.

Attorneys on all sides have said they wanted to avoid trial so Dugard did not have to testify, but that now seems unlikely in Nancy Garrido’s case, Tapson said.

“Nancy never wanted her to have to testify,” said Tapson. “She said that long ago and wanted a reasonable sentence, which the district attorney has rejected now.”

Dugard has said through her spokesman that she would be willing to testify if the cases went to trial.

Tapson said the initial offer to his 55-year-old client was 40 to 50 years in prison, which meant she could likely get out after 30 years. Tapson said the district attorney had increased that offer to 183 years to life.

Prosecutor Pierson has said Tapson’s comments asking for compassion for Nancy Garrido were offensive.

Phillip Garrido’s maximum sentence in the case would be 563 years to life.


Associated Press writers Lisa Leff and Marcus Wohlsen contributed to this report.

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond make the Tahoe Tribune's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.