Editorial: Still no answers about police survey
May 16, 2008
We’re still waiting, and so is the public. On May 8 and 9, the Tribune wrote four stories documenting the overall negative summary report of a South Lake Tahoe Police Department climate survey. The 10-page document ” which starts out by saying it is a brief summary of a 44-page report ” describes results of a survey completed by 37 members of the police department. The summary found that the majority of respondents did not trust or have confidence in department management. Police Chief Terry Daniels described the survey results as preliminary and said the findings needed to be validated and interpreted by the consultants.
After the Tribune stories were published, we e-mailed nine additional questions to City Manager David Jinkens and six to Daniels.
On May 8, we e-mailed Jinkens these questions:
— When will the full, 44-page climate document be made public?
— Why, after seven months, is it (the 44-page document) still in “draft” form?
— Who donated the money to have the study done, and how much did it cost?
Recommended Stories For You
— Why weren’t public police funds used to hire Taylor-Nelson (who conducted the survey), since on the surface it seems like a legitimate expenditure of money?
— Are police contract negotiations complete?
— Is the police contract actually in place?
— Which other city employees, in addition to yourself, have testified before the El Dorado County grand jury during its current term?
— How much has the city paid in legal fees in connection with this grand jury investigation?
This was Jinkens’ response the same day:
Later that day, the Tribune e-mailed Jinkens these additional questions:
— Have police contracts been ratified departmentwide? If not, which positions have had new contracts ratified?
— Are there still positions at the police department who are undergoing contract negotiations? If, so which members?
Jinkens responded that the city Human Resources Department could provide that information, and we subsequently received what we asked for later that day.
But since we had received no answers to any of our other questions we originally e-mailed May 8 (presumably because city officials wanted to meet with the city attorney), we again e-mailed the same questions plus a few more to Jinkens and Daniels on Thursday afternoon. By then, city officials would have had about four days to meet with the city attorney.
Here is Jinkens’ prompt e-mail response to the Tribune on Thursday afternoon:
As you’ll note from our list of questions, we didn’t ask Jinkens if he or City Council members had a copy of the full, 44-page report. Instead, we wanted answers to questions we did ask.
Jinkens’ response that “the remainder (of the) questions are ones that others should address” skirts the issue.
Who else will answer the questions?
Jinkens followed up with another e-mail on Thursday, saying, “No one is hiding from you or your questions. We can answer some questions and can not answer others for reasons explained to you by the City Attorney and me.”
Daniels, for his part, hasn’t responded to our latest queries, nor has he attempted to e-mail or speak to the Tribune since our stories ran.
Reporter Adam Jensen twice has called Taylor-Nelson LLC, the company that prepared the police department climate survey. On one occasion, nobody answered, and on the second try, he left a message. So far, no return call.
Unfortunately for the public, this has all the earmarks of an attempted whitewash.
So much for accountability.
Trending In: Opinion
- Letter: Vote ‘yes’ on Measure T in South Lake Tahoe (opinion)
- Letter: Consider fees, not a ban, to fix VHR issues (opinion)
- Letter: ‘Thank you for keeping me updated’
- Guest column: Progress made on workforce housing but more can be done (opinion)
- Letter: Jessica Morse the right choice for Congress (opinion)
- El Dorado County supervisor candidates find some common ground on VHR regulations
- Authorities recover body from 1,062 feet in Lake Tahoe (updated)
- What lies in the depths of Lake Tahoe’s waters? (video)
- Whittell celebrates Lisa Maloff, football team crushes Smith Valley at new digs
- Re-vamped Apple Hill shuttle gets a test drive