Tahoe Law Review: Endurance horseback riding injury leads to lawsuit
Our Tahoe-Truckee economy is recreation-based. Name the sport — it’s done in our Sierra region.
There is an entire body of law involving recreational activities where the participant is deemed to have “assumed the risk” of injuries inherent in the activity, and thus has given up the right to sue. The public policy is to encourage recreation.
The “Law Review” has briefed lots of assumption of risk cases, including ski and boarder injuries, water skiing and tubing, baseballs and even “bean balls,” baseballs that hit fans, bicycle races, touch football (the first case in California), bumper cars, skateboarding, errant golf balls, horseback trail riding, and the “walk into burning man embers” case. All upheld assumption of the risk.
Plaintiff Kathleen Swigart and defendant Carl Bruno participated in an American Endurance Ride Conference- sponsored, long-distance horseback riding event in Perris, California. Probably similar to the 100-mile Western States (Tevis) Trail Ride.
Forty-nine riders participated in the event, collecting playing cards at set checkpoints along the way. The horses have to pass veterinarian testing.
Both Swigart and Bruno were very experienced endurance riders, each having won many events.
Less than two hours into the ride, seven horses were close together in a single line with Swigart in front, Bruno in the rear, and Diane Stevens immediately in front of Bruno. At the 8-mile checkpoint, Swigart dismounted to retrieve cards for all of the riders in the group, as Stevens and Bruno were slowing down from behind.
Bruno’s horse bumped the rear of Steven’s horse, Steven’s horse then kicked Bruno’s horse, Bruno was thrown and his horse bolted forward striking and injuring Swigart, who was standing with the playing cards. Swigart sued Bruno.
Trail riding trivia. Some trail-riding horses wear red ribbons on their tails “to designate a horse likely to kick on a trail ride.” Don’t follow them.
RELEASE OF LIABILITY FORM
Before participating in the endurance ride, Swigart signed a form “release of liability.” The court of appeal did not rule on whether the release would hold up legally, it did not need to opine.
However, I will opine. If the release was properly drafted, it would have been another basis for Bruno to escape liability. Carefully drafted, and there is an art, release of liability forms are usually enforceable.
ASSUMPTION OF THE RISK
The trial court ruled for Bruno, Swigart appealed. The California Court of Appeal also ruled for Bruno, citing the law that a participant in an active sport or recreational activity who is negligent and injures another is liable only if the participant intentionally injures another participant or engages in conduct that is so reckless as to be totally outside the range of the ordinary activity involved in the sport.
A recreation event host or participant may not increase the risks inherent in the sport.
‘BEHAVING AS A HORSE’
The court of appeal viewed the evidence and used common sense (as the court wrote) concluding that horse tailgating during endurance trail events is common, adding, “we know that horses, by their nature, are unpredictable and difficult to control. There is always a risk, merely by ‘behaving as a horse’… a horse with its rider will cause injury.”
Take that cowboys — partner Pete Cuttitta and buddy Tom Archer.
The court ultimately found that Bruno’s horse acted like horses are known to do. Unfortunately, Swigart was injured but has no recourse. If everyone in an endurance ride could sue if injured, there would be no more endurance rides.
Jim Porter is an attorney with Porter Simon licensed in California and Nevada, with offices in Truckee and Tahoe City, California, and Reno, Nevada. His practice areas include: real estate, development, construction, business, HOA’s, contracts, personal injury, accidents, mediation and other transactional matters. He may be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org or http://www.portersimon.com.
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond make the Tahoe Tribune's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.