Brooke Laine: Complete disregard for law, transparency and honesty among South Lake Tahoe officials (opinion)
Editor’s note: The Tribune, as of the printing of this guest column, has been unable to independently verify the “violations of law” laid out in this piece. This column was originally submitted to local media outlets as a letter to the community on Sunday, April 15.
I am providing the following information because I can no longer be a party to the violations of law, secrecy, manipulation, lies and power struggles that are rampant at the city today.
There appears to be a complete disregard on the part of politicians and appointed officials for state law, transparency, and honesty to the public. The interim city attorney has admitted to many that a recent contract she oversaw violated the Brown Act (think Mary Egan contract).
To this day, that contract has never been addressed, corrected or publicly acknowledged. Multiple violations of law have occurred in closed session, often relating to discussions involving personal attacks on non-agenda issues.
The interim city attorney and the politicians engaged in the violations refused to cease the unlawful discussions, even when asked to do so to avoid continuing the unlawful conduct. In addition, the minutes of the March 20, 2018 meeting seriously misstated the facts by asserting an action occurred at a prior meeting, but the council never took that action. The law requires the city to tell the public the truth, follow the law explicitly, and provide accurate public records. This absolute failure at the very top, is a violation of law, injures the public’s trust, and is currently crippling the city.
Secrecy has no place in local government. If one councilmember is not privy to the same information as other councilmembers, the question is, “why?” If one, two, or worse, three councilmembers, discussing information the others don’t have, not only is that also a violation of the Brown Act, it creates distrust. It results in decision-making taking place outside of the public’s view (another violation of law) and it literally has no place in our city.
The only purpose of such secrecy is to shift the balance of power from the council as a whole to a few electeds and appointed staff. Worse yet, blindsiding some people through this type of manipulation, fuel the public’s distrust of process, transparency, and government in general.
Power struggles, when the struggle for power is not for the benefit of public policy, but rather for personal gain, are selfish, create hostility and purposely keep many in the dark. The public is a witness to this, which creates confusion and increases distrust.
Further, the media that buys into the incomplete and inaccurate information they are fed, unwittingly become tactical participants in this sport to gain personal power. Most importantly, the public’s business is not a priority.
I care deeply about this community. I always endeavor to hold myself to strong ethical and moral standards, as I feel every elected official should. I respect and hold in high regard the law that dictates how we as local leaders are to govern. It is my belief that the only way to address these serious violations, which illustrates a fundamental and complete breakdown of legal process, is to bring this information to the attention of the community.
I can no longer be a party to this unethical, hostile, distrustful environment that currently exists. I have opposed these tactics both publicly and privately, and tried to stand against the illegal and improper actions I have witnessed. However, this burden has become so heavy.
Today, I am choosing to shine light where it is necessary because I believe our community deserves better. Together, we can do better.
Brooke Laine is an elected member of South Lake Tahoe City Council.
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond make the Tahoe Tribune's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User
Several weeks ago this column addressed Senate Bills 9 and 10, both of which deal with the controversial issue of housing policy and, more specifically, density of housing. Taxpayer advocates and neighbor associations have opposed…