Police: Elderly women drugged homeless men before deaths | TahoeDailyTribune.com

Police: Elderly women drugged homeless men before deaths

Andrew Glazer

LOS ANGELES (AP) – Two elderly women accused of killing homeless men in hit-and-run crashes to collect their life insurance drugged the victims before running them over slowly with cars, authorities said Thursday.

“If they were awake it would be a slow painful death,” Deputy District Attorney Shellie Samuels said outside the courtroom after a judge postponed the arraignment of Olga Rutterschmidt, 73, and Helen Golay, 75.

“We think they drugged them with pills or alcohol first, then ran over them,” police Detective Dennis Kilcoyne said earlier in a prepared statement.

The court appearance came a day after the women were released from federal custody and re-arrested on state murder charges.

Both women answered “yes” when asked if they agreed to the postponement but said nothing else during the proceedings.

Arraignment was rescheduled for Aug. 29.

Attorney Roger Jon Diamond, who represents Golay, sought the delay for reasons that were not made public.

Police also said they were trying to locate three men whose names were found on applications for $800,000 in life insurance. They were identified as Nicolas Koos, 66; Jimmy Allen Covington, 46; and Scott B. Gones, whose age was not immediately known.

Detectives believe Covington may be in the San Francisco Bay area.

The two women each face two counts of murder and two counts of conspiracy to commit murder for financial gain in the deaths of Paul Vados, 73, in November 1999 and Kenneth McDavid, 51, in June 2005.

The murder charges carry special allegations that could make the women eligible for the death penalty if convicted.

Authorities alleged that Golay and Rutterschmidt befriended the two transients, convinced the men to sign them on to their life insurance policies and then collected some $2.3 million after they were killed. Federal agents have seized the money.

“These people are not your grandmothers,” Kilcoyne said at a news conference.

The investigation was launched last year when police looking into McDavid’s death found similarities to the Vados case. “We started with this farfetched story of a couple of women in this fantastic scheme,” Kilcoyne said.

Investigators learned the women met 20 to 30 years ago while posing as guests at tony Beverly Hills and Brentwood hotels in order to lounge poolside.

Surveillance teams never saw the women together, but insurance investigators discovered both their names listed as beneficiaries on the policies of the dead men.

Last November, undercover police officers reported seeing Rutterschmidt in a car, guiding Josif Gabor, an elderly blind man, to sign several documents. He might have been the next target of the scheme, Kilcoyne said.

Federal authorities arrested the two women in May and charged them with mail fraud in connection with the insurance scheme while the murder investigation progressed.

Police said they found what appears to be McDavid’s tissue and blood on a Mercury Sable station wagon linked to his death. Investigators also said they have records to show both women bought the vehicle in 2004 and stored it at Golay’s house.

The car was later abandoned and sold off for storage fees. Kilcoyne said the family that bought it drove the car for months before the human tissue was discovered.

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond make the Tahoe Tribune's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.