California, Tahoe-area tree deaths climb to record levels thanks to bugs, drought
By the numbers*
28 million: Number of trees dead or dying in California
93,167: Number of trees dead or dying within Tahoe National Forest
35,038: Number of trees dead or dying within Lake Tahoe Basin
Source: U.S. Forest Service Aerial Survey. *Figures are estimates, and are as of the end of 2015.
Visit tahoe.livingwithfire.info to learn all sorts of tips and information about Sierra trees and how to live in a fire-prone area.
TRUCKEE, Calif. — Twenty-eight million.
That’s the estimated number of trees in California that were dead or dying in 2015 as a result of the ongoing drought, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
The 28 million figure is not only a record-high for the state, it’s roughly 10 times more dead trees than were recorded in 2014 — just one year prior — by the U.S. Forest Service Aerial Survey team.
In other words, California’s tree mortality is rising at a historic rate and showing no signs of slowing down.
“We’ve had four years of drought, and it’s just compounded year after year,” said Rita Mustatia, a silviculturist (a person who looks after trees in the forest) with the U.S. Forest Service Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit. “We need a couple normal winters in a row — similar to this year — to bring us back to some sense of normalcy.”
According to the U.S. Forest Service, Forest Health Monitoring Program, Region 5, there was an estimated 35,038 dead or dying trees within the Lake Tahoe Basin in both Nevada and California by the end of 2015, with 11,215 acres affected by mortality.
Meanwhile, the Tahoe National Forest — which extends east of Sacramento, through the foothills and across the Sierra crest to the California state line — showed roughly 93,167 dead or dying trees and 33,266 acres of mortality.
“The tree mortality issue is definitely a top priority because we’re behind the curve,” Mustatia said. “With all these trees toppling over on the ground, you’re just looking at a gigantic fuel load of dead trees.”
Indeed, the drought has led to millions of California and Sierra Nevada trees deprived of water. This, Mustatia said, results in swaths of trees that become stressed, consequently losing their ability to fight off the attacks of bark beetles.
“The trees need water to survive, but also to protect themselves from insects that bore into the tree and create galleries where they lay their eggs,” said Mustatia, who went on to explain the breakdown of a tree’s defense system. “The trees use the water to create a pitch to push the beetles out of the tree. And if they don’t have the water, they can’t use that mechanism to keep the beetles from attacking.
“They can stand some of the attacks, but if the beetles are aggressive and able to continue to attack … the trees will eventually succumb to that.”
At Lake Tahoe, the Jeffrey pine beetle — described by USFS as the primary insect pest of the pine trees — is the most prevalent, Mustatia said.
But they are not the only borers on the North Shore. Additionally, Ips engraver beetles infest red and white fir trees in the region, she said.
“And then,” Mustatia continued, “the beetles use a pheromone to attract other beetles if they are happy with the area, and draw more beetles to attack that tree — that’s how the spread continues.”
In fact, in some areas of the state, primarily Southern California, the beetles are adapting to the warmer climates and subsequently having more than one life cycle, Mustatia said.
“You’re basically looking at double the insects,” she said.
THINNING THE PROBLEM
For Lake Tahoe, the bark beetle epidemic, thus far, is minimal compared to other pockets of the state, said Jeff Dowling, the North Tahoe Basin forester with Calfire.
“We haven’t yet seen a significant increase in the amount of mortality driven by the drought on the east slope of the Sierra,” said Downing.
Pausing, he added, “The insects are always in the system; that goes on whether we’re in a normal participation cycle or not.”
So what can be done to help save our drought-stricken trees?
Dowling, who has worked for Calfire for over 30 years, points to a method that may seem counterproductive to the general public: tree thinning.
“Here, locally, where we’ve aggressively gone out and thinned spans (of trees), we are not seeing mortality in the numbers we might see had we not aggressively thinned,” Dowling said.
Essentially, too many trees on too few acres creates a logjam, if you will, in the forests. This results in suffocated trees fighting for moisture, sunlight, and nutrients — especially during this unprecedented drought.
Tree thinning, meanwhile, helps alleviate the trees’ fight for survival, agreed Mustatia.
“I attribute some of the healthier forests in Lake Tahoe to eliminating so much of the competition,” she said. “You’re creating a healthier forest. The trees that we left on the ground have more water available to them.
“I think if we hadn’t done some of that (thinning) in the last four years we might be seeing a lot more (tree deaths) than what we are.”
Another method used to help maintain a healthier forest is prescribed fire, said Forest Schafer, who is, fittingly, a forester with the Incline Village-based North Lake Tahoe Fire Protection District.
“There’s an increased use in prescribed fires because it mimics the natural role the wilderness plays in the Sierra Nevada ecosystem in magnitude, diversity and resilence,” Schafer explained. “We have fire-adaptive ecosystems; it evolves with fire, and fire is a necessary part of our environment.”
Quite simply, fire removes dead accumulations as well as young trees that are not as fire-adaptive. With fewer trees to compete for water, the ones left can grow strong and be less susceptible to fires and more capable of pitching out bark beetles.
For instance, Dowling said, on the east side of the Sierra at lower elevation, more frequent fires would stamp out the small trees in the brush and give the large trees — the pines — more space for sustainability.
“Prescribed burning is a really useful tool to keep forests healthy and reduce those fuels,” added Bill Seline, deputy chief of the Truckee Fire Protection District. “And keep fires from getting too big — unnaturally big.”
The truth of the matter is, Seline said, during the drought the trees are so dry that as soon as the snow melts, forests in the region and state will begin to experience midsummer fire behavior.
For property owners of Truckee-Tahoe, Seline said the most important thing to do is create and manage defensible spaces.
Notably, a law enacted in 2005 requires defensible space clearance — in other words, decreasing the amount of fuels — around homes and structures to remain at 100 feet.
“We realize that it takes a lot of work and diligence for property owners to manage that,” he said. “But, it’s not if a fire will start in Truckee, it’s when — is your house defensible?
“If a tree dies in someone’s front yard because it was drought stressed and a beetle took over and killed, now you have a dead tree in a person’s property and of course it’s a fire risk.”
With that in mind, Dowling said homeowners should routinely keep a sharp eye on the health of their trees, especially when the Tahoe fire season heats up this summer.
“If they start to see a tree’s not looking as green as they did, they need to pay close attention to whether or not they’re seeing pitch running out of the trees,” Dowling said. “If the tree does indeed die, they need to get it cut as soon as they possibly can. Because the longer you let the tree sit there, the opportunity for the insects to escape and move to another tree increase.
You may be able to stop them from emerging and getting to another tree.”
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around the Lake Tahoe Basin and beyond make the Tahoe Tribune's work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Your donation will help us continue to cover COVID-19 and our other vital local news.